Exfoliation is a hot topic amongst skincare experts. When done correctly, it can smooth out your skin's texture, reduce fine lines, and keep breakouts at bay. When done incorrectly, though, it can lead to a host of issues, including a damaged skin barrier. Before you freak out, don't worry. With the right expert advice and knowing when to exfoliate in your routine, you'll get it right. We asked experts for a bit of advice on this topic to get the full rundown for each skin type. For all their advice, keep scrolling below.
Our Top Pick for Mature Skin: PCA Skin Revitalizing Mask ($68)
Our Top Pick for Acne-Prone Skin: Paula's Choice 2% BHA Liquid Exfoliant ($35)
Our Top Pick for Sensitive Skin: Cosmedix Surface Revival ($70)
Our Top Pick for Combination Skin: Kate Somerville ExfoliKate Intensive Exfoliating Treatment ($78)
Our Top Pick for Normal Skin: Grown Alchemist Polishing Facial Exfoliant ($67)
Our Top Pick for Dry Skin: Ursa Major Fantastic Face Wash ($11)
Our Top Pick for Oily Skin: Dermalogica Daily Microfoliant Exfoliator ($66)
Chemical vs. Physical Exfoliants
For reference, "chemical" exfoliants usually contain acids like alpha hydroxy (glycolic and lactic), beta hydroxy (salicylic), and polyhydroxy. "Mechanical" or "physical" exfoliants are scrubs, sugars, loofahs, or brushes.
There is a lot of debate amongst skincare experts about physical exfoliants with some saying that they can cause micro tears in the skin if you're not careful. If you scrub too hard or the particles in your scrub are too large or sharp, this can occur. "Any scrubs with large particles like apricot pits should be avoided, as they can cause micro-tears in the skin—at any age," says board-certified dermatologist and founder and director of Chicago Cosmetic Surgery and Dermatology Carolyn Jacob, MD, FAAD. "Anything that is too drying or used too frequently should also be avoided."
Chemical exfoliants, believe it or not, are a bit more gentle on the skin. Jacob, adds, "Chemicals may sound more aggressive yet can often be gentler than mechanical exfoliants, which are physical scrubs."
If you have sensitive skin, you'll want to start slow, though. "A good starting point is to just start incorporating a mild chemical exfoliating cleanser or wash into your routine once a week," suggests Caroline Robinson, MD, FAAD, board-certified dermatologist and founder of Tone Dermatology.
Chemical exfoliants can be a great addition to your routine, but you also have to be careful not to over do it. "Over-exfoliation (either using products that are too harsh or exfoliating too often) should be avoided as this can damage the skin barrier and lead to inflammation and irritation," says board-certified dermatologist Carolyn Stull, MD.
Why Exfoliation is so Important
In addition to sloughing off dry skin, exfoliation helps reduce the appearance of dull skin and uneven skin tone. It can help prevent breakouts. It can make your other products work even better. And it especially helps as you get older and your skin doesn't have as much cellular turnover and sebum production slows—exfoliation can stimulate new cell growth.
A good exfoliation routine can start in your early 20s. "We actually start to get one of the first signs of aging—dullness—and that starts to appear around 25 or so, when you just notice that your skin isn't as glowy, and so incorporating some exfoliation, starting with that change, is important," Robinson says.
The Best Exfoliants for Each Skin Type
Skincare is super individualized, so of course, everyone has different exfoliation needs, and it all depends on your skin type. I asked dermatologists to break it down for me.
First, Stull has a few recommendations. "Alpha-hydroxy acids including glycolic acid, lactic acid and mandelic acid have humectant and keratolytic properties, meaning they help draw moisture into the skin while providing exfoliation. As a result, these agents are well-suited for most skin types including sensitive skin." For acne-prone skin, Stull has another recommendation. "Salicylic acid is an exfoliant that also helps regulate sebum production, and can be a good choice for those with oily, acne-prone skin."
For the best picks for each skin type, take a peak below.
The Best Exfoliants for Mature Skin
"Most mature skin tends to be a bit drier, so enzymes are a good choice, like those found in the Revitalizing Mask by PCA Skin," adds Jacob. "Some mature skin can experience menopausal acne, but it can't be treated the same way we treat teenage acne. Gentle exfoliants, retinols, and peels are still a good choice for them. "
This gentle AHA toner contains hydrating lactic acid and azelaic acid to gently exfoliate the skin.
You can also try an exfoliating mask, like this glycolic acid peel. In 10 minutes, the product works to remove dead skin cells and brighten your complexion.
The Best Exfoliants for Acne-Prone Skin
Woolery-Lloyd recommends once- to twice-weekly exfoliation with chemical products like salicylic acid or glycolic acid. She says you can even use it daily if there is no irritation.
This gentle exfoliating serum contains mandelic acid and is perfect for many skin types, but it's especially great for skin that's barrier damaged, acne-prone, sensitized, and easily irritated.
This treatment mask from IS Clinical starts as a gentle scrub and then turns into an enzyme mask that decongests the skin without redness or irritation.
The Best Exfoliants for Sensitive Skin
Sunday Riley's brightening, hydrating, and clarifying treatment serum works great for most skin types, but if your skin is sensitive, this might be your ticket. Lactic acid is one of the most gentle AHAs and it simultaneously hydrates while it exfoliates.
This super gentle toner from Cosmedix brightens the skin, hydrates, and exfoliates with lactic acid.
This scrub both has chemical and physical exfoliants to buff away dead skin, promote cell turnover, and leave skin looking flawless. It's got a light water-gel texture, so it will feel so soothing on skin.
The Best Exfoliants for Combination Skin
Formulated for normal and combination skin, this daily exfoliator has natural quartz, sodium bicarbonate crystals, and pumpkin and pomegranate extracts to remove dead skin cells. And it doesn't leave your skin dried out, as brown sea algae provide moisture.
Drunk Elephant's Babyfacial peel contains a 25% AHA blend and 2% BHA to exfoliate skin and support cell turnover. It's recommended to use this once weekly.
Designed for people with dry, normal, combination, and oily skin, this product is a cleanser, scrub, peel, and mask in one. Ingredients include natural AHAs, silica, lactic acid, and fruit enzymes. It's recommended to use this once or twice a week.
The Best Exfoliants for Normal Skin
This gentle face polish from Grown Alchemist is a physical exfoliant, but it's incredibly gentle with bamboo particles and contains additional botanical extracts like grapefruit and peppermint leaf. This may work best for normal skin types. Physical exfoliants definitely aren't always bad. If your skin barrier isn't compromised, the right physical exfoliant might be just what you need.
The Ordinary's toning solution is good for all skin types and works to reduce dullness and uneven texture. Along with 7% glycolic acid, it contains Tasmanian pepperberry derivative, ginseng root, and aloe vera to soothe and brighten.
This is another recommendation from Robinson, who says it "has a blend of salicylic acid and glycolic acid as well as several antioxidants for gentle exfoliation and brightening."
The Best Exfoliants for Dry Skin
Robinson recommends this face wash, which she says has a blend of both AHAs and BHA for uniform gentle exfoliation.
Along with microbeads, this gentle scrub has soy extract and jojoba and castor oils to leave the skin soft and radiant.
This mask from Tata Harper contains a self-neutralizing AHA along with microbiome-balancing prebiotics that exfoliate and revive dull, dry skin. It also helps support a healthy skin barrier.
The Best Exfoliants for Oily Skin
"Oilier skin can handle more frequent exfoliation and can benefit from the application of charcoal to remove oil and debris," Jacob says. "The Detoxifying Mask from PCA Skin is a great choice."
This cleanser is formulated with three acids—salicylic, lactic, and glycolic—to gently exfoliate. It's also got sodium PCA, which leaves the skin hydrated.
This one from Dermalogica is a rice-based powder that gently micro-exfoliates.
-
Megan Fox *Finally* Let Us in on Her Skincare Secrets—This Is the Buzzy Serum She Swears ByTrust me. This one is worth it.
-
Traveling Wreaked Havoc on My Skin—These Hero Products Basically Pressed "Undo"They provided a serious reset.
-
I'm Always Skeptical of Skin Supplements, But This One Really Surprised MeThey're now a lifelong staple.
-
I Tried This New Mineral SPF—Fast-Forward and I've Worn It Every Day for a MonthIt immediately became my new fave sunscreen.
-
I've Been a Dermatologist for Over 40 Years—18 Products I Trust to Use on My Own SkinDr. Loretta shares her best skincare advice.
-
17 Iconic French Pharmacy Products I Picked Up During a Week in ParisI was determined to fit them in my suitcase.
-
The $8 Face Oil Kendall Jenner Uses to Prep Her Skin for French-Girl MakeupPlus, her favorite anti-acne face wash.
-
These Undetectable Tinted Moisturizers Actually Meet Our Super-High StandardsThey won't let you down.
